BBC Doctor Who - The Stories BBC
QuickNav to a Season: 
QuickNav to a Story: 
 
The Previous Story
The Lie of the Land
 The Previous Story
The Previous Story
(The Pyramid at the End of the World)
 The Next Story
(Empress of Mars)
Season
Details
SynopsisGeneral
Information
The
Episodes
Audience
Appreciation
ArchivesNotesFirst and LastThe PlotQuote of
the Story
Release
Information
In PrintPhoto
Gallery
 

Peter Capaldi
The Lie of the Land
Twelfth Doctor Logo


Synopsis


Bill's Mum
Bill's Mum
 Earth has been invaded and Bill is living alone, an isolated figure surviving in occupied Britain.

 The Doctor is imprisoned and appears to be on the side of the enemy, flooding the airwaves with fake news.

 Bill and Nardole must embark on a deadly mission to rescue The Doctor and lead the resistance against the new regime, whatever the cost.

Source: BBC Website


General Information

Season: Thirty Six (New Series 10)
Production Code: 10-8
Story Number: 271 (New Series: 115)
Episode Number:835 (New Series: 139)
Number of Episodes: 1
Percentage of Episodes Held:100%
Production Dates: January - February 2017
Broadcast Date: 03 June 2017
Colour Status: HD Colour
Studio: BBC Wales (Roath Lock Studios, Cardiff)
Location:
Writer:Toby Whithouse
Director:Wayne Yip
Producer:Nikki Wilson
Executive Producers:Brian Minchin and Steven Moffat
Assistant Directors:Lauren Pate and Rhun Llewelyn
Script Executive:Lindsey Alford
Script Supervisor:Nicki Coles
Script Editors:Nick Lambon and Emma Genders (Assistant)
Editors:Edel McDonnell, Becky Trotman (Assistant) and David Davies (Assistant)
Head of Production:Gordon Ronald
Production Executive:Tracie Simpson
Production Manager:Adam Knopf
Production Assistants:Jamie Shaw and Virginia Bonet
Post Production Supervisor:Samantha Price
Production Designer:Michael Pickwoad
Director of Photography:Stuart Biddlecombe
Casting Director:Andy Pryor CDG
Line Producer:Steffan Morris
Costume Designer:Hayley Nebauer
Make-Up Designer:Barbara Southcott
Cameramen:Dan Patounas (Assistant), Drew Marsden (Assistant), Gethin Williams (Assistant) and Mark McQuoid (Operator)
Visual Effects:BBC Wales VFX and MILK
Special Effects:Real SFX
Prosthetics:Millennium FX
Special Creature Effects:Millennium FX
Stunt Co-ordinator:Crispin Layfield
Stunt Performers:Joel Conlan, Sarah Lochlan and Troy Kenchington
Incidental Music:Murray Gold
Special Sounds (SFX Editor):Harry Barnes
Sound Recordist:Deian Llyr Humphreys
Music Orchestrated By:Alastair King
Music Conducted By:Alastair King
Music Performed By:The BBC National Orchestra of Wales
Music Recorded By:Gerry O'Riordan
Music Mixed By:Jake Jackson
Title Sequence:Billy Hanshaw
Title Music:Ron Grainer and the BBC Radiophonic Workshop. Arranged by Murray Gold
Number of Doctors: 1
The Doctor: Peter Capaldi (The Twelfth Doctor)
Number of Companions: 2The Companions: Matt Lucas (Nardole) and Pearl Mackie (Bill Potts) Guest Cast: Michelle Gomez (Missy) Additional Cast: Emma Handy (Mother), Beatrice Curnew (Group Commander), Stewart Wright (Alan), Solomon Israel (Richard), Jamie Hill (Monk), Rosie Jane (Bill's Mum)Setting: Great Britain (2017) Villain:The Monks

The Episodes

No. Episodes Broadcast
(UK)
Duration Viewers
(Millions)
In Archive
835The Lie of the Land03 June 201744'44"4.8Yes

Total Duration 45 Minutes


Audience Appreciation

Average Viewers (Millions) 4.8
Doctor Who Magazine Poll (2017)64.30%  (Position = 12 out of 12)
Doctor Who Magazine Poll (2023) Position = 28 out of 35


Archives


 This story exists and is held in the BBC's Film and Videotape Library.



Return to the top of this page
 


Notes


This story is the third and final part of three loosely connected stories known as "The Monks Trilogy". This story continues on after Bill Potts gives her consent to The Monks to save The Doctor who is trapped in a laboratory that is about to explode (see the previous story "The Pyramid at the End of the World"). Bill and Nardole have to find a way to rescue The Doctor after he is imprisoned, and end The Monk's invasion of Earth. We also get to see him enter the Vault to consult Missy, revealing his endeavour to turn her from her destructive past to a path of ‘good’.

This story has been written by Toby Whithouse - making this his sixth Doctor Who story; his most recent being the 2015 two-part story "Under the Lake/Before the Flood". He also who wrote "School Reunion", "The Vampires of Venice", "The God Complex" and "A Town Called Mercy". This is the first time he has written for a returning enemy.

This story was directed by Wayne Yip. Although this is his first Doctor Who story he was at the helm for two episodes of the BBC Three spin-off series Class. Wayne Yip's other previous credits include Secret Diary of a Call Girl (which starred Billie Piper), Utopia and Misfits.

The read through for this story took place on the 11th January 2017. Filming started five days later, as part of Block Six along with the subsequent story "Empress of Mars", on the 16th January and was completed on the 22nd February.

For this story The Doctor has a change of costume, reverting to the ensemble first seen during the flashback sequences in "Extremis". This costume was designed by Costume Designer Hayley Nebauer.

Nardole is seen performing a Tarovian neck pinch to knock out Alan, using only his thumb. Ian Chesterton demonstrated a similar act on Ixta in the 1964 First Doctor story "The Aztecs". Nardole confirms that he has reached the level of Brown Tavard in Tarovian martial arts.

Nardole mentions being contaminated by Raoultella Planticola (see "The Pyramid at the End of the World") and states it laid him up for six weeks.

Nardole again hints at his cybernetic nature (see "The Return of Doctor Mysterio", "The Pilot" and "The Pyramid at the End of the World") when he tells the group invading the pyramid that his left hand is not his original hand but is one that he won in a game.

In the first scene with Missy, the visual of two eyes superimposed over a panning shot is a homage to a similar scene from the 1996 Eighth Doctor film "Doctor Who: The Movie". In that story, when The Master is introduced, we see two planets morph into his eyes. At that moment The Doctor is recounting a request made by The Master that meant the two Time Lords meet up again. In this story the effect follows The Doctor making requests, providing a neat inversion of the original ‘eyes across a scene’ motif.

In the 2015 story "The Magician's Apprentice/The Witch's Familiar" Missy previously scoffed at the idea that she had ‘turned good’ when questioned by Clara Oswald. As early as his seventh incarnation, The Doctor had vowed to one day save his friend after The Master was forced to revert following a temporary spell as the kindly John Smith (see the Big Finish Productions audio story "Master").

Missy continues to demonstrate her skill on the piano. When The Doctor and Bill first visit her in the vault we hear her briefly playing selections from Erik Satie’s Gnossienne No 1 and later in the visit she picks out a little of Scott Joplin’s The Entertainer - an altogether more upbeat classic from 1902.

Missy is heard to ask for some ‘toys’ like a particle accelerator, a 3D printer and a pony, in return for her help.

The Doctor deduces that The Monk statues around the world act as beacons for the false propaganda. The Monks have erected these statues in cities including Bristol, New York City, Paris, Moscow, Sydney and Toronto, among others. Statues have also been erected near famous locations, including Mount Rushmore, Niagra Falls and Stonehenge.

The Monks propagate falsehoods through Bill, and have injected themselves into all of human history - taking credit for all of humanity's achievements.

In images showing The Monks' aid to humanity brief clips showing the Daleks, the Cybermen and Weeping Angels are seen at the beginning of this story. ‘Who can forget the time the Monks defeated the Daleks, the Cybermen, the Weeping Angels?’ The Doctor’s voice-over is accompanied by brief clips from "Into the Dalek", "Nightmare in Silver" and "Blink". To further add to the broadcast’s sense of untruth, the first two excerpts aren’t even set on Earth. Later in the story we also see several moments from "The Pilot" and in the central chamber of The Monk's pyramid there are still images from other scenes from the current season.

It is revealed that Time Lords can apparently 'fake' a regeneration seemingly by starting the process only to abort it before any actual healing, if needed, is enacted.

No scenes featuring the TARDIS were shot for this story. This is unusual since the show was revised in 2005 but not unique as the TARDIS did not feature in "Mission to the Unknown", "Doctor Who and the Silurians", "The Mind of Evil", "The Dæmons", "The Sea Devils", "The Sontaran Experiment", "Genesis of the Daleks" and "Midnight". We do however, glimpse a fraction of the TARDIS very briefly in this story when Bill mentally fights The Monks in the central chamber of their pyramid.

The Vault is dimensionally transcendental like some other Time Lord technology.

The Doctor is located on an old prison ship off the East coast of Scotland.

UK locations on Nardole's map include: Birmingham, Liverpool, Manchester, Leeds, Edinburgh, Glasgow and Aberdeen. Other UK locations include the Hebrides, the Orkney Islands and the Shetland Islands.

Magpie Electricals makes a return. Just after the opening titles we see Bill watching one of The Doctor's broadcasts that is being shown on several televisions in a shop called Magpie Electricals. It has similar (but not quite identical) branding as we have seen on Magpie Electricals goods - such as the guitar amplifier in the 2015 story "The Magician's Apprentice/The Witch's Familiar" and Martha’s television in the 2007 Tenth Doctor story "The Sound of Drums/Last of the Time Lords" - and on Magpie Electrical outlets, including the store in "The Beast Below" and the business which apparently started it all - Mr Magpie’s corner shop in London, as introduced in the 2006 Tenth Doctor story "The Idiot’s Lantern".

Although not named in this story, altered versions of the Lascaux cave paintings, Leonardo da Vinci's Vitruvian Man and the Mona Lisa appear. Each of these is altered to incorporate The Monks. Photos also appear of The Monks with Thomas Edison, Albert Einstein, Neil Armstrong and Winston Churchill.

The Doctor suggests that he would make some modifications to history, like ending racism and people who talk in cinemas.

The Doctor explains that Bill is unaffected in ‘Fake News Central’ because they are at the eye of the storm.

To gain Bill's trust, Nardole tells her they went to Australia on the run from ‘The Heather Creature’ (see "The Pilot") and that space doors should go ‘shuck, shuck’ (see "Oxygen").

In testing Bill we hear The Doctor telling her about the creature under the Thames (see "Thin Ice").

It is revealed that The Doctor had Bill write a 3000 word essay on free will, which she never completed due to The Monk’s invasion.



First and Last

The Firsts:

 The first Doctor Who story to be directed by Wayne Yip.


The Lasts (Subject to Future Stories):

 The last of three loosely connected stories known as "The Monks Trilogy".


Return to the top of this page
 


The Plot

WARNING: May Contain SpoilersHide Text
The Lie of the Land

Broadcasting Fake News
Broadcasting Fake News

After giving her consent to The Monks, so as to save The Doctor and to return his sight (see "The Pyramid at the End of the World"), Bill Potts, along with the rest of humanity, are now under the leadership of The Monks.

The Monks however, give the impression that they have been on Earth for millions of years having guided human development. Bill and some others though are aware of the truth that The Monks have only been present on Earth for the last six months. Those that promote this are imprisoned for ‘memory crimes’. To remind the population of The Monks apparent good intent The Doctor appears on television praising the Monks' guidance over humanity.

Bill keeps herself grounded in reality by imagining that she is talking with her long-dead mother, based on pictures The Doctor gave her. Nardole, also aware of the truth, locates Bill and helps her to find the prison hulk where The Doctor is thought to be captive. After a team of commandoes swarm inside, The Doctor tells Bill he is cooperating willingly with The Monks, believing that humanity is doomed without their guidance.

A Confused Bill
A Confused Bill

A distraught Bill grabs a gun off of one of the soldiers and shoots The Doctor, who appears to begin regenerating, but quickly stops. The entire scenario is revealed to have been a test by The Doctor, Nardole and the team, to make sure Bill was not under the influence of The Monks.

Back at St Luke’s University, where The Doctor and Bill work, The Doctor, Nardole and Bill enter the Vault to talk to Missy, who says she has encountered The Monks before. She confirms that The Monks maintain control by broadcasting a signal containing a false history to their subjugated victims through numerous statues that they have built across Earth. This is enabled by a psychic link established through the person who originally gave ‘consent’. Missy also reveals that she defeated The Monks, during her own encounter with them, by killing that individual. This revelation therefore implies that Bill must die as she is the one who gave consent on Earth.

Bill's Mum
Bill's Mum

Believing there must be another solution, The Doctor, Bill, Nardole, and the commandoes infiltrate The Monks' pyramid in London so that The Doctor can hijack their broadcast with his own mind to break the psychic transmission.

In the central chamber, The Doctor attempts to link his mind to the controlling Monk. But after a struggle The Doctor is overpowered. With The Doctor severely weakened this leaves only Bill to put a stop to The Monks.

To the horror of The Doctor and Nardole it seems that Bill, heading the words given by Missy, intends to sacrifice herself by linking her own mind to The Monk's despite The Doctor's protests. The Monks' broadcast is replaced with images of Bill's mother, which The Doctor recognises as a strong and loving memory in Bill's mind. Encouraging her to continue Bill is able to break The Monks transmission.

Nardole
Nardole

Now aware of The Monks' lies humanity revolts against them. The Doctor, Bill, and Nardole watch as The Monks abandon Earth – departing in their pyramid.

Sometime later, The Doctor and Bill find that most of humanity have no recollection of The Monks. In the Vault, Missy expresses remorse for those she has killed.

 
Shooting The Doctor
Shooting The Doctor
Fake Regeneration
Fake Regeneration
Missy
Missy
The Doctor In Trouble
The Doctor In Trouble
 
A Monk
A Monk
Bill Takes Control
Bill Takes Control
Overpowering The Monks
Overpowering The Monks
The Monks Revealed
The Monks Revealed




Quote of the Story


 'You had free will, and look at what you did with it. Worse than that, you had history. History was saying to you, "Look, I've got some examples of fascism here for you to look at. No? Fundamentalism? No? Oh. Okay. You carry on." I had to stop you, or at least not stand in the way of someone else who wanted to. Because the guns were getting bigger, the stakes were getting higher, and any minute now, it's gonna be "Goodnight, Vienna".'

The Doctor



Return to the top of this page
 


Release Information

FormatTitleRelease Date (UK)Code NumberCover ArtRemarks
Video
DVD
Doctor Who Series 10 Part 2 Box SetJuly 2017BBCDVD 4203Photo-montageDVD boxed set containing 5 stories
Video
Blu-Ray
Doctor Who Series 10 Part 2 Box SetJuly 2017BBCBD 0395Photo-montageBlu-Ray boxed set containing 5 stories
Video
DVD
The Complete Tenth Series Box SetNovember 2017BBCDVD 4224Photo-montageDVD boxed set containing 12 stories
Video
Blu-Ray
The Complete Tenth Series Box SetNovember 2017BBCBD 0406Photo-montageBlu-Ray boxed set containing 12 stories
Video
Blu-Ray
The Complete Tenth Series Box Set (Limited Edition Steelbook)November 2017BBCBD 0421Photo-montageLimited Edition Blu-Ray Steelbook boxed set containing 12 stories
Video
Blu-Ray
The Complete Tenth Series Box Set (Limited Edition UK Exclusive Steelbook)November 2017BBCBD 0421Photo-montageLimited Edition (UK Exclusive) Blu-Ray Steelbook boxed set containing 12 stories


In Print

No Book Release
Doctor Who Magazine - PreviewIssue 513 (Released: July 2017)
Doctor Who Magazine - ReviewIssue 514 (Released: August 2017)

Return to the top of this page
 


Photo Gallery


The Doctor and Companions

 
Peter Capaldi
The Twelfth Doctor

   

Matt Lucas
Nardole
 
Pearl Mackie
Bill Potts
   




On Release

DVD Part 2 Box Set
DVD Part 2 Box Set

BBC
VIDEO
Blu-Ray Part 2 Box Set
Blu-Ray Part 2 Box Set

BBC
VIDEO
Complete Series DVD Box Set
Complete Series DVD Box Set

BBC
VIDEO
   
Complete Series Blu-Ray Box Set
Complete Series Blu-Ray Box Set

BBC
VIDEO
Complete Series Blu-Ray Limited Edition Steelbook Box Set
Complete Series Blu-Ray Limited Edition Steelbook Box Set

BBC
VIDEO
Complete Series Blu-Ray Limited Edition (UK Exclusive) Steelbook Box Set
Complete Series Blu-Ray Limited Edition (UK Exclusive) Steelbook Box Set

BBC
VIDEO
   


Magazines

Doctor Who Magazine - Preview: Issue 513
Doctor Who Magazine - Preview: Issue 513

Marvel Comics
 
Doctor Who Magazine - Review: Issue 514
Doctor Who Magazine - Review: Issue 514

Marvel Comics
   

Return to the top of this page
 
 
Who's Who
KJ Software
Who Me
Episodes of the
Twelfth Doctor


Season 36 (New Series 10) Press to go back to the previous visited page References
 
 
Doctor Who is the copyright of the British Broadcasting Corporation. No infringements intended. This site is not endorsed by the BBC or any representatives thereof.